The Tommy Diehl Outstanding Wrestler Award is given annually to any senior Fort Hill Wrestler that is :
- A Varsity Letter Winner
- Has Outstanding Wrestling Ability
- Demonstrated Leadership
- Had Loyalty to Team and Coaches
- Demonstrated Sportsmanship
1978 Craig Gerherd
1979 Howard Blank
1980 Howard Blank
1981 Mark Yoder and Roy Butch Haller
1982 Jack Gerhard
1983 Troy Hamilton
1984 Troy Hamilton
1985 Dave Thomas
1986 Paul Thomas and Mike Gelles
1987 Eric Liller
1988 Bill Dumphy
1989 Danny Bowser
1990 Dave Phillips
1991 Brian Dawson
1992 Brian Kurtz and Rob Dawson
1993 Rob Dawson
1994 Steve Allen
1995 Andy Cornwell
1996 Louie Schadt
1997 Buddy Van Meter and Louis Schadt
1998 John Squires
1999 Nathan Weaver
2000 NO AWARD GIVEN
2001 Cody Mackie
2002 Roy Payne
2003 Austin Williams
2004 Jason Oates
2005 Justin Sirbaugh
2006 Michael Yost
2007 Justin Nichols
2008 Jake Merritt
