McDonogh goalkeeper Ali Brennan (four saves) didn't surrender a goal during the second half and both overtime periods in the Eagles' 1-1 tie at Spalding on Tuesday.
Players battle for possession in the midfield during a 1-1 tie between Spalding an McDonogh on Tuesday.
by Aaron Gray
agray@digitalsports.com

Archbishop Spalding High School girls soccer coach Bob Dieterle looked at his bottle of Pepsi as being half full during a post-game pizza party with the rest of the team.

"Hey, at least it's not a loss," he told his players.

There's no question about it, the Cavaliers are battle-tested. Of their eight games this season, five have gone into overtime, including a rematch with the team that knocked them out of the playoffs last season -- McDonogh.

Sophomore striker Maggie Morrison scored in the 25th minute for host Spalding and senior midfielder Gigi Mangione got her team on the board in the 10th as the IAAM A Conference juggernauts battled through two scoreless 10-minute extra periods ending in a 1-1 tie Tuesday.

The result for the No. 6 Cavaliers (6-1-2 overall, 3-0-1 in conference) was better than Monday night's 3-2 double-overtime loss to Good Counsel, out of Washington D.C. Dieterle said he was happy to see his players respond to their first loss of the season.

"We were on the short side of that one so I wanted to see how they would come back today," Dieterle said. "The girls were ready to play. Games like this one and the other overtime games, along with the difficulty of our schedule, is going to make this team better and better as the season goes along."

Physical fitness hasn't been a problem for the No. 1 Eagles (9-0-1, 3-0-1). Their midfielders had range all over the field and when the team met after the first extra period, coach Maurice Boylan said its performance during the first overtime session was the best soccer McDonogh had played in the game.

"We scored first, we dominated play and we felt we had more chances," said Boylan, whose team surrendered its first goal of the season to league competition. "It's always a tough game here at Spalding ... their girls are very athletic and there's a lot of speed on that team."

Playing on the road, the Eagles knew they would have to take command early. In the 10th minute, the Spalding defense gave Mangione an inch and she took advantage of it.

The senior captain cut the ball outside from 15 yards out and blasted a low left-footed shot into the far-side netting for the first goal.

"Ashley Pivey had it and it sort of popped out," Mangione said. "I saw the corner and went for it. Even though we scored, I think it's still disappointing that we didn't finish all of our opportunities."

Spalding countered quickly with long balls for Morrison and senior striker Erica Page to run on to. One of the serves came from deep in the Cavaliers' midfield and it found Morrison on the left flank. She collected the ball, eluded her defender and tucked the ball past junior goalkeeper Megan Lerner (three saves), who came off her line to intercept.

"We actually did the same exact play in one of earlier games," said Morrison, who scored her third goal of the season and her second in as many nights. "I was a little nervous going in because I've missed a lot of open shots lately but she had the confidence and played me a great ball."

Morrison, a second-year varsity player, usually comes off the bench to bring a spark to the Spalding offense.

"Maggie brings a lot of energy to the team and leaves everything out on the field," Dieterle said. "She attacks and that's what good strikers do."

Both teams had their chances in the extra periods. Spivey had a look in the second period but her shot from the left side caught a piece of a Spalding defender and sophomore goalkeeper Jocelyn McCoy had to dive to her left for one of her 10 saves in the game.

Less than a minute later, McDonogh senior goalkeeper Ali Brennan left the penalty box to make a kick save during a Cavalier possession.

"I think the whole defense did a great job of shutting down some of their top players," said Dieterle, who holds a 6-2-1 series record over McDonogh since taking over at Spalding in 2002. "This is a young group and they're learning with each game.”

McDonogh (9-0-1)    1    0    0    0    -    1
Spalding (6-1-2)       1    0    0    0    -    1
GOALS: McD - Mangione; AS - Morrison. ASSISTS: McD - Spivey. SHOTS ON GOAL: McD - 11; AS - 8. SAVES: McD - Brennnan 4, Lerner 3; AS - McCoy 10. CORNERS: McD - 2; AS - 0.